With so many choices between external and internal DVD drives how can you tell that you are getting the best value and performance?
Today most new computers are shipping with multiple USB ports and SATA drive interfaces for harddrives and CD/DVD/Blu-Ray drives. You can generally assume that the industry makes these across the board changes in hardware options because its: cheaper, in demand by consumers, and technologically better-faster. The days of IDE or PATA are probrably coming to an end soon. The reason you can find new IDE drives in the store right now is that they are inexpensive and for what most people require out of a drive they provide basically identical performance to an SATA interfaced drive. It seems that harddrive technology is slower to evolve than the interface technology of SATA and IDE. The ultimate bottleneck to harddrive and CD/DVD ROM speed is how fast the drive can find data on the magnetic platters. Currently there is no difference between SATA and IDE drives in this area other than the performance rating in RPM speed and seek time for any particular drive.
So what should you get? IDE or SATA? I would suggest that you get SATA for the simple fact of its technologies usable life compared with IDE. SATA will really only show speed benefits when running multiple drives on your system simultaneously (133 MB throughput of EIDE vs 150MB and up for SATA) If you are running a single harddrive in your system you wouldnt notice any real improvements.
Now what about external drives? You typically have the choice between USB and Firewire. USB being the industry leader - USB is far more affordable and available. But the issues of speed are the same here too because seek and read times are the important criteria. These criteria are inherent in the drive technology itself and not the interface technology of USB or Firewire. But Firewire in its most recent enhancements is still faster than USB but you wouldnt notice unless you had multiple drives plugged into the interface.
But what about external versus internal drives? Internal are cheaper because of them being less popular and portable. External are easier for the typical user to install without outside help. Another thing to consider is that USB works very well with external harddrives and CD/DVD/Blu-Ray but problems were more common in its earlier incarnations however IDE or SATA have been more likely to work out of the box without trouble.
With the introduction of SSD (solid state drives) to the mainstream consumer we may see a better reason to choose SATA over IDE and Firewire over USB. The seek times of SSD are far superior to the magnetic platter harddrives we were used to. But time and price will be the determining factor there too.








